Jonathan Bain
Humanities and Social Sciences
Polytechnic Institute of New York University

STS3003 - Seminar in Science and Technology Studies
[Home]
Prof:  Jonathan Bain Spring 2010
Office:  RH 201A Tu/Thurs 12:30 - 1:50
Off. hrs: Weds 1:00 - 2:00 or by appt.    
phone:  260-3688

I.  Description
This is a seminar on recent work in Science and Technology Studies (STS).  STS is an interdisciplinary field in which methods from history, philosophy, sociology, and literary and cultural studies are used to analyze the relations among science, technology and society.  This course is a core requirement for STS-majors. For non-STS majors, the purpose of this course is to increase understanding of the ways in which science and technology interact with society, and to become familiar with humanistic and social scientific modes of thought.  For Spring 2010, the seminar will focus on material cultures of practice in histories of physics and engineering in 19th and 20th century Britain and the U.S.  Prerequisite:  One Level 2 course from the STS cluster of HuSS electives.

II.  Required Reading
At Bookstore:
  1. Marsden, B. and C. Smith (2007) Engineering Empires, Palgrave Macmillan.
  2. Warwick, A. (2003) Masters of Theory:  Cambridge and the Rise of Mathematical Physics, Univ. Chicago Press.
  3. Kaiser, D. (2005) Drawing Theories Apart:  The Dispersion of Feynman Diagrams in Postwar Physics, Univ. Chicago Press.
  4. Shapin, S. (2008) The Scientific Life:  A Moral History of a Late Modern Vocation, Univ. Chicago Press.
Additional Reading:
  1. Smith, C., et al. (2003) "'Avoiding equally extravagance and parsimony':  the Moral Economy of the Ocean Steamship", Technology and Culture 44, pp. 443-469.
  2. Smith, C. and A. Scott (2007) "'Trust in Providence':  Building Confidence into the Cunard Line of Steamers", Technology and Culture 48, pp. 471-496.
  3. Gooday, G. (2005) "Fear, Shunning, and Valuelessness:  Controversy over the Use of 'Cambridge' Mathematics in Late Victorian Electro-Technology", in D. Kaiser (ed.) Pedagogy and the Practice of Science, MIT Press, pp. 111-149.
  4. Kaiser, D. (2005) "Making Tools Travel:  Pedagogy and the Transfer of Skills in Postwar Theoretical Physics", in D. Kaiser (ed.) Pedagogy and the Practice of Science, MIT Press, pp. 41-74.
  5. Shapin, S. (2007) "Science and the Modern World", in E. Hackett et al. (eds.) The Handbook of Science andTechnologyStudies, 3rd Ed., MIT Press, pp. 433-448.
  6. Shapin, S. (2006) "The Man of Science", in L. Daston and K. Park (eds.) The Cambridge History of Science, Vol. 3, Cambridge Univ. Press, pp. 179-191.


III.  Requirements
1.  Participation in class discussion (20%).  Each student will be required to submit a list of 5-7 questions (typed, double-spaced) on the assigned reading at the start of every class.  Students should keep a copy of their questions during the class discussion.

2.  Depending on class size, one or two presentations of a reading assignment (20%).

3.  Three papers.
(a) Two Response Papers of 4-6 pages (30%, @15% each).
(b) One Research Paper of 8-10 pages (30%).  The research paper will be a critical extension, based on instructor feedback, of one of the response papers from item 3(a).
(c) All papers must conform to writing guidelines handed out and discussed on the first day of class.
(d) Late paper policy:  Late papers will be accepted but will be given an initial penalty of a third of a grade point, and a further penalty of a third of a grade point for every period of 4 days after the due date.  Example:  An A paper turned in one day late will receive an A-; an A paper turned in 4 days late will receive a B+; an A paper turned in 8 days late will receive a B; etcLate papers will not be accepted after the final day of the seminar.


VI.  Class Schedule
The following schedule may need to be revised over the course of the semester.  The reading assignments must be completed by the date on which they appear.
Week 1 Tues 1/19
Course intro
Thurs 1/21
Smith, et al.:  "The Moral Economy of the Ocean Steamship"
Week 2 1/26.
Smith, et al.:  "Building Confidence into the Cunard Line of Steamers".

1/28
Engineering Empires
Intro & Chap 1:  pp. 1-40.
Week 3 2/2.
Engineering Empires
Chap 2:  pp. 41-88.
2/4.
Engineering Empires
Chap 3:  88-128.
Week 4 2/9.
Engineering Empires
Chap 4:  pp. 129-177.
2/11.
Engineering Empires
Chap 5 & Conclusion:  pp. 178-258.
Week 5 2/16.
No Class

2/18.  Paper #1 due.
Masters of Theory
Chaps 1 & 2:  pp. 1-113.
Week 6 2/23.
Masters of Theory
Chaps 3 & 4:  pp. 114-226.
2/25.
Masters of Theory
Chap 5 & 6:  pp. 227-356.
Week 7 3/2.
Masters of Theory
Chaps 7 & 8:  pp. 357-442.
3/4.
Masters of Theory
Chap 9 & Epilogue:  pp. 443-511.

Week 8 3/9.
Gooday:  "Fear, Shunning, and  Valuelessness".
3/11.
Kaiser:  "Making Tools Travel".
Week 9 3/16.
Spring Break

3/18.
Spring Break
Week 10 3/23.
Drawing Theories Apart
Chaps 1 & 2:  pp. 1-59.
3/25.  Paper #2 due.
Drawing Theories Apart
Chaps 3 & 4:  pp. 60-172.
Week 11 3/30.
Drawing Theories Apart
Chaps 5 & 6:  pp. 173-252.
4/1.
Drawing Theories Apart
Chaps 7 & 8:  pp. 253-317.
Week 12 4/6.
Drawing Theories Apart
Chaps 9 & 10:  pp. 318-388.
4/8
Shapin:  "Science and the Modern World", and "The Man of Science".
Week 13 4/13.
The Scientific Life
Chaps 1 & 2:  pp. 1-46.
4/15.
The Scientific Life
Chaps 3 & 4:  pp. 47-126.
Week 14 4/20.
The Scientific Life
Chaps 5 & 6:  pp. 127-208.
4/22
The Scientific Life
Chap 7:  pp. 209-268.
Week 15 4/27.  Research Paper due.
The Scientific Life
Chap 8 & Epilogue:  pp. 269-314.